Inquiry Regarding the Issuance of a Notice to Explain (NTE) Due to Refusal to Participate in a Survey for Overseas Training

---

Letter of Concern

Dear Attorney,

I hope this letter finds you well. I am writing to seek legal advice regarding a recent situation I encountered at work. My superior issued me a Notice to Explain (NTE) for allegedly refusing to respond or marking "NO" in a survey related to an overseas training opportunity. I am concerned about whether the issuance of an NTE under such circumstances is appropriate or in line with labor laws in the Philippines.

Could you kindly advise me on whether my employer has the right to issue an NTE based solely on my response or non-participation in the survey? I would also appreciate guidance on how I should respond to the NTE, what my legal rights are in this situation, and any potential implications this may have on my employment status.

I look forward to your advice.

Sincerely,
[Concerned Employee]

---

Comprehensive Analysis on the Issuance of a Notice to Explain (NTE) in the Context of Employee Participation in Surveys

In the Philippine employment context, a Notice to Explain (NTE) is typically issued as part of a due process requirement when an employee is alleged to have committed a violation of company policies or rules. Before delving into the specifics of your concern, it is important to understand the legal framework governing NTEs, employee rights, and employer obligations, as well as the disciplinary process that surrounds such notices.

1. The Legal Basis of a Notice to Explain (NTE)

A Notice to Explain (NTE) is an essential component of the due process requirement under Philippine labor law. Specifically, under Article 292(b) (formerly Article 277(b)) of the Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended by Republic Act No. 6715, an employee may only be terminated for just causes, and due process must be observed in cases of disciplinary action. Due process has two facets:

• Substantive Due Process, which refers to the presence of a valid ground or just cause for taking disciplinary action.
• Procedural Due Process, which involves the proper observance of the twin notice rule: (1) a notice of the charge or the NTE, and (2) a notice of decision after a hearing or the employee’s explanation.

The issuance of an NTE serves as the first notice. It informs the employee of the allegations against them and gives them an opportunity to respond. The NTE is a critical part of ensuring that an employee is not arbitrarily disciplined without the chance to present their side of the story.

2. Employee Participation in Company Surveys: Is It a Duty?

Your specific concern centers on whether refusing to answer or answering "NO" to a survey for overseas training can be grounds for an NTE. To address this, the following legal principles and factors must be considered:

A. Nature of the Survey and Its Relation to Employment Obligations

The first step in determining whether the NTE is valid is to examine the nature of the survey and how it relates to your duties as an employee. Generally, companies may distribute surveys for various reasons, such as gauging employee interest, gathering feedback, or determining eligibility for certain programs (e.g., overseas training). However, not all surveys carry the same weight in terms of an employee’s obligation to respond.

• Mandatory Surveys vs. Voluntary Surveys: If the survey is an essential part of your duties, particularly if it directly impacts your role or professional development (such as training required for job performance), the company may have a legitimate interest in ensuring that employees participate. On the other hand, if the survey is simply to gauge interest or gather optional feedback, then the employee may not necessarily be under a strict obligation to answer.
• Company Policies: Another key factor is whether there are specific policies or guidelines within your company that govern survey participation. Some organizations include clauses in their employee handbooks or contracts that obligate employees to comply with directives such as surveys, especially if they pertain to work performance or career development opportunities.

It is important to carefully review your employment contract, employee handbook, or any relevant memos to determine whether survey participation falls within your obligations as an employee. If there is no clear obligation, the issuance of an NTE might be premature.

B. Right to Refuse and Employee Autonomy

Under Philippine labor law, employees retain certain rights to autonomy, including the right to choose whether to participate in optional activities that are not directly tied to their core responsibilities. Refusing to answer a survey, particularly one that is not mandatory or does not directly affect job performance, may not constitute insubordination or a just cause for discipline.

• Insubordination under the Labor Code refers to the refusal to obey lawful and reasonable orders from a superior that are related to the employee's duties. If the survey does not fall under this category, the refusal to answer may not qualify as insubordination.

In this light, if the survey was voluntary or merely designed to gauge interest, it may be questionable for your superior to issue an NTE on the grounds of refusal or disinterest.

3. Just Causes for Issuing an NTE

For an employer to lawfully issue an NTE, it must be based on one of the just causes for termination or discipline outlined in Article 297 (formerly Article 282) of the Labor Code. These include:

1. Serious misconduct or willful disobedience of the lawful orders of the employer in connection with the employee's work.
2. Gross and habitual neglect of duties.
3. Fraud or willful breach of trust.
4. Commission of a crime.
5. Other analogous causes.

In the scenario you described, the question is whether answering "NO" or failing to answer a survey constitutes serious misconduct or willful disobedience. This largely depends on the context of the survey. If it was mandatory and essential to your role or career development, the employer may argue that failure to participate constitutes a refusal to comply with a lawful order.

However, if the survey was merely a way to gauge interest in optional overseas training, it is unlikely to meet the threshold of willful disobedience or serious misconduct. The employer would need to establish that there was a clear directive requiring participation and that your refusal significantly impacted the company's operations or your duties.

4. Procedural Due Process: Responding to the NTE

When you receive an NTE, it is crucial to respond promptly and comprehensively. Your response should:

1. Acknowledge the NTE and the allegations contained therein.
2. Present your side of the story—whether you indeed refused to answer the survey, and if so, why. Provide explanations as to whether the survey was mandatory or voluntary and whether you were aware of any obligation to participate.
3. Cite any company policies that support your stance, if applicable. If there are no clear policies obligating you to respond to the survey, this strengthens your defense.
4. Maintain professionalism in your response to avoid escalating the issue unnecessarily.

Your response should be in writing and submitted within the timeframe specified in the NTE. By doing so, you fulfill the procedural requirement of being heard, which is vital in protecting your rights.

5. Potential Consequences and Remedies

The consequences of failing to adequately respond to an NTE can vary. If the company finds your explanation insufficient, they may impose disciplinary actions ranging from a written reprimand to suspension or termination, depending on the gravity of the alleged offense. However, it is important to note that any disciplinary action taken must be proportionate to the offense.

If you believe that the issuance of the NTE or any subsequent disciplinary action is unjust, you have the right to:

• File a grievance through your company’s grievance machinery, if available.
• File a complaint with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) for illegal dismissal, unfair labor practices, or violation of labor standards.
• Seek legal counsel to evaluate the possibility of filing a case for constructive dismissal if you are forced to resign due to the unfair treatment.

6. Final Considerations

The legality and appropriateness of issuing an NTE based on refusal to answer or participating in a survey largely depend on the context and specific circumstances of your employment. If the survey was voluntary or unrelated to your job performance, the issuance of an NTE might be unwarranted and could expose your employer to claims of harassment or arbitrary action. On the other hand, if participation in the survey was a reasonable expectation based on your role, it could form part of the employer's right to enforce discipline.

In conclusion, it is vital to thoroughly assess the following:

• The nature of the survey (mandatory or voluntary).
• Company policies regarding survey participation.
• Your employer’s just cause in issuing the NTE.
• Your ability to respond effectively within the procedural framework.

Seeking further legal assistance is advisable to navigate this issue and ensure that your rights are protected.

---