Legal Recourse for Employees Facing Bullying and Coercion from CEOs: Filing a Complaint with DOLE

---

Letter to Attorney:

Dear Attorney,

I am writing to seek your legal advice on an issue I am currently facing at my workplace. My concern revolves around a situation where a CEO appears to be engaging in bullying behavior aimed at forcing employees to resign. This includes verbal harassment, threats of termination, and actions that create a hostile work environment. I would like to understand whether the affected employees have a strong legal case if they were to file a formal complaint with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) or other relevant agencies.

Is this considered a valid ground for filing a complaint under labor laws in the Philippines, and what would be the possible outcomes of such a complaint?

Thank you in advance for your guidance.

Sincerely,
An Oppressed Employee

---

Comprehensive Legal Discussion: Workplace Bullying and Coercion in the Philippines: Can an Employee File a Complaint with DOLE?

In the Philippine labor landscape, employees are entitled to certain fundamental rights that protect their dignity, security of tenure, and overall welfare in the workplace. A scenario where a CEO or any high-ranking official engages in bullying or harassment of an employee with the intent of coercing that employee to resign is both a violation of these labor rights and contrary to the principles of fair employment.

In response to your query, this article will explore the legal frameworks and remedies available to employees who experience bullying from their employer, especially if the bullying is done with the intention of compelling resignation. We will discuss the Department of Labor and Employment's (DOLE) role, relevant laws such as the Labor Code of the Philippines, the Anti-Sexual Harassment Act, the Safe Spaces Act, and the principles surrounding constructive dismissal. Finally, we will consider possible courses of action and the strength of an employee's case when filing a complaint against a bullying employer.

1. Understanding Bullying in the Workplace

Workplace bullying is a form of harassment that may involve repeated, unreasonable actions of individuals (or a group) directed towards an employee, with the objective of humiliating, degrading, undermining, or intimidating them. It may come in various forms such as verbal abuse, isolation, excessive monitoring, assigning impossible tasks, or even using threats of termination.

Under Philippine labor laws, bullying, especially by someone in a position of authority like a CEO, can be classified as harassment or unjust treatment. Harassment, when directed at an employee for the purpose of forcing resignation, becomes an even more critical issue as it touches upon the principle of "constructive dismissal."

2. Constructive Dismissal: Coercing an Employee to Resign

In cases where an employer, through bullying or harassment, creates an environment that is so unbearable that the employee feels compelled to resign, this can be considered constructive dismissal. Constructive dismissal occurs when the resignation is not truly voluntary but rather made under circumstances where the employee is left with no reasonable option but to resign due to intolerable working conditions imposed by the employer.

In such cases, the resignation letter provided by the employee does not extinguish the employer's liability. Instead, the law treats the resignation as a dismissal, and the burden is on the employer to prove that such a resignation was voluntary and not coerced through harassment, bullying, or other forms of maltreatment.

Legal Basis of Constructive Dismissal

Section 297 of the Labor Code of the Philippines specifically deals with illegal dismissal and outlines the requirements for a valid dismissal, which include just or authorized causes for termination as defined by law. When an employee resigns due to circumstances that have been deliberately orchestrated by the employer to make working conditions unbearable, the resignation can be deemed involuntary. Constructive dismissal is, therefore, considered a form of illegal dismissal.

The employee, in such cases, may file a complaint for illegal dismissal, and if the complaint is found to have merit, the employee may be entitled to reinstatement without loss of seniority, back wages, and other benefits.

Jurisprudence on Constructive Dismissal

Philippine courts have consistently ruled that constructive dismissal occurs when an employer creates working conditions so difficult or unpleasant that a reasonable person in the employee’s position would feel compelled to resign. For instance, in the case of Globe Telecom, Inc. v. Florendo, the Supreme Court ruled that when an employer’s actions, such as demotion, reassignment, or harassment, leave the employee with no reasonable choice but to resign, this is tantamount to dismissal, and the employer bears liability for damages.

3. Filing a Complaint with DOLE: The Role of DOLE in Labor Disputes

The Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) plays a critical role in addressing labor disputes, including cases of harassment, constructive dismissal, and unfair labor practices. An employee who believes they are being bullied into resignation can seek redress by filing a formal complaint with DOLE, specifically through the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or the Single Entry Approach (SEnA) program.

The NLRC and Filing a Complaint

The NLRC is the quasi-judicial body under DOLE that handles labor disputes, including cases of constructive dismissal. An employee who has resigned due to bullying and harassment may file a complaint with the NLRC, where an investigation will be conducted to determine whether the resignation was indeed forced or if the employee was constructively dismissed.

Single Entry Approach (SEnA)

Before escalating a dispute to formal litigation through the NLRC, DOLE requires that parties first undergo a mandatory conciliation-mediation process known as SEnA. This process allows employees and employers to settle disputes amicably before they become formal cases. During the SEnA process, DOLE mediators facilitate discussions between the employee and the employer, seeking to resolve the issue without the need for a more formal complaint.

If an agreement is reached, it will be documented and binding on both parties. However, if no settlement is achieved, the employee may proceed to file a formal complaint before the NLRC.

4. Additional Legal Protections: Anti-Sexual Harassment Act and the Safe Spaces Act

While the central concern raised relates to bullying aimed at forcing resignation, it is also important to discuss other relevant laws that may provide additional protections to employees facing harassment.

Anti-Sexual Harassment Act of 1995 (RA 7877)

While the Anti-Sexual Harassment Act primarily addresses harassment based on sex, it is worth mentioning that this law also provides for remedies in situations where an employer uses their authority to harass subordinates. Harassment under this law can take the form of verbal, non-verbal, or physical actions, and it includes any acts that impair an employee’s ability to work with dignity.

Should the bullying behavior include sexual advances or innuendos, the employee may also file a case under this law.

Safe Spaces Act (RA 11313)

The Safe Spaces Act or Bawal Bastos Law offers comprehensive protection against all forms of gender-based harassment, including those that happen in the workplace. This law covers all kinds of verbal, physical, and psychological harassment and applies whether the victim is male or female. The act also extends to power dynamics between a superior and subordinate, thus encompassing situations where a CEO bullies an employee.

Under the Safe Spaces Act, employees have the right to a workplace free from any kind of harassment, including bullying that leads to psychological distress or resignation. Violations of this law may lead to penalties not only for the CEO but also for the company if it fails to act on complaints.

5. Possible Outcomes of Filing a Complaint

Filing a complaint with DOLE or the NLRC could result in several possible outcomes, depending on the merits of the case:

• Reinstatement: If the employee is found to have been constructively dismissed, the NLRC may order their reinstatement to their former position without loss of seniority rights or other privileges.

• Payment of Back Wages: In cases of constructive dismissal, the employer may be ordered to pay back wages from the time the employee was wrongfully dismissed until the date of reinstatement.

• Separation Pay: If reinstatement is no longer feasible due to strained relations between the employee and employer, the NLRC may instead award separation pay in lieu of reinstatement.

• Damages: Depending on the nature of the harassment and bullying, the employer may also be ordered to pay moral and exemplary damages. This would be particularly applicable if the harassment caused significant emotional or psychological harm to the employee.

6. Final Thoughts

Employees who are subjected to bullying and harassment, particularly from individuals in positions of authority such as a CEO, have strong legal grounds to file complaints with the Department of Labor and Employment. Bullying that is intended to force an employee to resign can constitute constructive dismissal, which is illegal under the Labor Code. Moreover, employees are also protected by other laws such as the Anti-Sexual Harassment Act and the Safe Spaces Act, which broaden the scope of protection against various forms of harassment.

It is critical for employees facing such situations to document instances of harassment, seek legal advice early, and file a complaint with DOLE or the NLRC to ensure that their rights are upheld and that they receive proper remedies.