Multiple Notarized Deeds of Sale for the Same Property in the Philippines

Written By Harold Respicio

Below is a broad, general-information overview of the legal concepts, procedures, and issues surrounding the situation of having multiple notarized deeds of sale for the same real property in the Philippines. This discussion is for educational purposes only and does not substitute for formal legal advice from a qualified attorney.

1. Introduction

In the Philippines, real property transactions are typically formalized through a deed of sale. Under Philippine law, the ideal method to secure one’s ownership and priority rights over a parcel of land is to have the deed of sale properly notarized and registered with the appropriate government offices. Problems arise when a single property is sold more than once to different buyers, each holding a duly notarized deed of sale. This situation can lead to complex legal disputes, commonly referred to as “double sale” or even “multiple sales.”

Understanding how the law treats multiple notarized deeds of sale is critical for any party involved in real estate transactions—buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate professionals.

2. Legal Bases and Key Statutory Provisions

2.1. Civil Code of the Philippines (Article 1544)

  • Article 1544 of the Civil Code lays out the framework for resolving cases when the same piece of real property is sold to different buyers. In simplified terms:
    • Priority by Registration: The buyer who first registers the sale in good faith with the Registry of Deeds has a superior right to the property.
    • Priority by Possession (in Good Faith): If none of the buyers registered the property, the buyer in actual possession who acted in good faith has a superior right.
    • Priority by Date of Deed: If neither registration nor possession applies (e.g., no one took possession or no one acted in good faith), the buyer whose deed bears the earliest date may have a superior right, though this scenario often requires court adjudication and fact-finding.

2.2. Property Registration Decree (Presidential Decree No. 1529)

  • PD 1529 governs land registration in the Philippines. It underscores the importance of prompt registration of deeds and other instruments affecting land. Once a deed is duly recorded with the Registry of Deeds, it serves as notice to third parties of the registered buyer’s claim over the property.

2.3. Notarial Law

  • A notarized deed of sale is a public document and enjoys a presumption of regularity. Notarization means the signatories appeared personally before a notary public, who verified their identities and affirmed that they freely executed the deed. However, mere notarization does not, by itself, confer absolute proof of valid conveyance if there is fraud or if the seller does not, in fact, have the right to sell the property to multiple people.

3. Key Concepts

3.1. Good Faith vs. Bad Faith

  • Good Faith: Generally means the buyer has no knowledge of any defect in the seller’s title, nor knowledge of any previous sale to another buyer. A buyer is deemed to be in good faith if they have exercised due diligence in verifying the seller’s ownership and encumbrances on the property.
  • Bad Faith: Arises when the buyer is aware that the property was already sold, or the buyer deliberately fails to investigate suspicious circumstances. A buyer who proceeds despite red flags risks losing claim or facing legal liability.

3.2. Priority Rules

  • Rule 1: The first in registration, in good faith, prevails. This means that registration at the Registry of Deeds effectively “locks in” the buyer’s claim—even if another deed of sale was executed and notarized earlier but not registered.
  • Rule 2: If no one registers, the buyer in possession in good faith prevails. “Possession” here typically means actual, physical occupation or at least acts of dominion (e.g., building a fence, constructing a house, cultivating the land).
  • Rule 3: If neither registration nor possession applies, the earliest dated, validly executed deed might prevail. Courts look at factual details to ascertain who, among the multiple buyers, has the superior right.

3.3. The Role of Notarization

While notarization gives a deed of sale a presumption of authenticity, it is only one aspect of perfecting the transfer of ownership. A notarized deed of sale is essential for registration purposes, but multiple notarized deeds on the same property are not unusual in fraud scenarios or unscrupulous dealings. Courts will look beyond the mere presence of notarization and examine the totality of the transaction: Who bought first? Did anyone register? Was there malice or fraud?

4. Common Scenarios Involving Multiple Notarized Deeds

  1. Seller Sells to Multiple Buyers Intentionally

    • A dishonest seller might execute multiple deeds of sale for the same property, each duly notarized, to collect multiple payments. This is the classic scenario of fraud.
    • The real dispute arises when different buyers discover they each have a notarized deed of sale. Legal remedies revolve around determining who registered first and/or who was in good faith and in possession.

  2. Sale to One Buyer, then Mortgage or Sale to Another

    • Sometimes the property is first sold to a buyer, but the seller subsequently executes another deed (a second sale) or mortgages the same property to someone else.
    • The second buyer or lender, if in good faith and if they manage to register ahead of the first buyer (who might have delayed registration), can obtain a superior right under Article 1544.

  3. Multiple Family Members Each Claiming Sale

    • Intra-family disputes may arise where multiple heirs or co-owners issue conflicting deeds. The question is whether all co-owners consented to the sale or who had the authority to sell.
    • In such cases, more formal legal scrutiny is applied to ownership documents and the authority of the person who sold the property.

5. Legal Effects and Consequences

5.1. Civil Liability

  • Rescission or Annulment of Subsequent Sales: If a buyer can prove that a later sale was executed in bad faith or fraud, a court may annul the subsequent sale.
  • Damages: A guilty seller who perpetrated multiple sales may be held civilly liable for actual damages, moral damages, and, in some cases, exemplary damages if the fraudulent conduct is proven.
  • Return of Purchase Price: If a buyer loses ownership due to a superior claim, they may seek reimbursement from the seller of the purchase price, plus potential damages.

5.2. Criminal Liability

  • Estafa (Swindling): A seller who knowingly sells the same property to multiple buyers, collecting multiple purchase amounts, can face criminal charges for estafa under the Revised Penal Code.
  • Falsification: If there are forged signatures, tampered documents, or any fraudulent notarial acts, the parties involved may also face criminal prosecution.

6. Remedies for Aggrieved Buyers

  1. Immediate Registration

    • The first and most crucial safeguard is to register the notarized deed of sale promptly with the Registry of Deeds. Delaying registration increases the risk that another party could record their deed first.

  2. Judicial Action to Quiet Title or Annul the Deed

    • Where multiple deeds exist, or there is a cloud on the title, a buyer can file an action to “quiet title,” asking the court to confirm their ownership and invalidate the subsequent (or prior) deeds.
    • Alternatively, a party can file a case to annul the second deed on grounds of fraud.

  3. Criminal Complaint

    • If there is clear fraud or bad faith by the seller (or by the second buyer acting in connivance with the seller), the aggrieved party can file a criminal complaint for estafa, among other possible charges.

  4. Injunction

    • In urgent cases, a party may seek a preliminary injunction to prevent the seller or a competing buyer from transferring or encumbering the property further until the dispute is resolved.

  5. Lis Pendens

    • When a legal action is pending, a notice of lis pendens can be registered to put third parties on notice that the property is under litigation.

7. Best Practices and Preventive Measures

  1. Conduct Thorough Due Diligence

    • Before buying real estate, secure a certified true copy of the title from the Registry of Deeds. Verify no adverse claims, liens, or encumbrances exist.
    • If the seller is not the registered owner, confirm any authority they have to sell (e.g., Special Power of Attorney, extrajudicial settlement among heirs, etc.).

  2. Notarize and Register Immediately

    • Have the deed of sale notarized and promptly registered. Notarization alone does not protect you against double sales if someone else manages to register an equivalent deed first.

  3. Possession and Inspection

    • After purchase, take possession of the property or otherwise assert dominion (e.g., fence it off, pay real property tax). Physical occupation strengthens your defense if a dispute arises.

  4. Check Seller’s Background

    • If possible, investigate whether the seller has a history of real estate dealings and if there are any pending disputes or red flags.

  5. Secure Title Transfer

    • After the deed is registered, proceed to have the title transferred to your name. Having the Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) or Condominium Certificate of Title (CCT) is a strong proof of ownership.

8. Special Considerations

8.1. Torrens System Reliability

  • The Philippine Torrens system under PD 1529 aims to provide certainty of ownership once a property is duly registered. Nonetheless, it can be undermined by unscrupulous conduct. A newly issued TCT in the buyer’s name is one of the strongest legal protections.

8.2. Notarization Irregularities

  • There have been instances where notarial seals or documents were fraudulently created. Always verify the notary public’s identity and commission details, and confirm that the notarial register is accurate.

8.3. Court Adjudication

  • When multiple notarized deeds exist, it often leads to litigation. Courts weigh the totality of evidence—who acted in good faith, which party registered or took possession first, whether there was fraud, etc. Court proceedings can be protracted and costly, reinforcing the importance of preventive measures.

9. Conclusion

Multiple notarized deeds of sale for the same property is a prevalent real estate pitfall in the Philippines. The Civil Code (particularly Article 1544) and related laws (PD 1529 on registration) provide a legal framework to determine who holds a superior right when these unfortunate situations arise. The cornerstone of protection remains in being a diligent, good-faith buyer, registering one’s purchase without delay, and taking possession of the property.

Should you find yourself in a scenario of multiple deeds or suspect possible fraud, it is crucial to consult with a Philippine attorney experienced in real estate and property law. Vigilance, documentation, and immediate registration cannot be overstated as the best proactive steps to protect one’s investment.

Disclaimer

This article provides general information on legal topics within the Philippine jurisdiction. It is not legal advice, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. For specific situations or in-depth counsel, please consult a qualified Philippine lawyer.Multiple Notarized Deeds of Sale for the Same Property in the Philippines

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Harold Respicio
Previous

Demolition of a House Without Court Order in the Philippines
Next

Hospital Bill Non-Payment Discharge Rights in the Philippines